Appendix: Measurement and Monitoring
The National Campus Energy Challenge will be based on the percent reduction
achieved in kWh and BTU from previous years rather than trying to compare between
dissimilar campuses. The competition identifies the 'most improved' campuses to avoid
comparing campuses of different types, climate zones, and scales.
Each campus establishes a baseline of the past three years’ data for February ('05, '06, and
'07) and reports this data through an online survey by Tuesday, February 5 at midnight
Eastern Time. After the February competition, each campus must report the same data set
for 2008 by Tuesday, March 18th at midnight Eastern Time.
How the data will be used
- All billing days will be normalized to a 28-day billing period (to compare equal-length
months).
- All monthly consumption estimates will be normalized to the baseline 3-year
average of the number of students on your campus. This is not to compare perstudent
energy intensity, but to adjust for any sudden changes in the size of the
student body. We do not adjust for area of campus buildings because this entails
additional energy waste unless also accompanied by a comparable rise in student
enrollment.
- Heating, but not electricity, will be normalized to the baseline 3-year average of
the heating degree days (HDDs) in your region to compare equal-intensity winters.
- Percent reductions between the three-year baseline and '08 consumption will be
determined by dividing the normalized '08 data by the normalized baseline data.
Energy savings for your college (not used in the competition, but reported) will be
calculated by subtracting the '08 consumption from the normalized baseline.
- For the combined heat-electricity awards, heating BTU will be converted as if that
amount of natural gas was burned to produce of electricity, instead of using the
amount of BTU a kWh of electricity produces, which ignores substantial
production inefficiency. Converting BTU to kWh requires the heat rate, which
depends on the type of power plant used. We use the conventional gas plant
estimate provided by the US Department of Energy, which is 10,807 BTU / kWh
(http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/aeo/assumption/pdf/electricity.pdf#page=3) .
Because we want to convert BTU to kWh, we use the inverse 1 kWh / 10,807 BTU
for the conversion factor = 0.0000925326 kWh / BTU. Though not needed for the
competition, since a kWh in direct energy =3413 BTU, the assumed efficiency
rate of electrical conversion is 3413 BTU / 10,807 BTU = 0.315813824 = 31.58%.
Important considerations
- Your billing period may not start on Feb. 1 and go to Feb. 28. It is acceptable to
use a different period as long as you report the exact number of days and it
corresponds generally to February and is similar to monthly billing periods in past
years. You probably will want to coordinate with Facilities so they can choose
when to start the billing period or at least you know when they will be measuring
and can coordinate actions to that period.
- Some Facilities departments may have trouble accurately reporting all this data.
Please walk through the process step by step beforehand to make sure every item
is clear and try to get data in as early as possible – if possible, submit baseline
data before the end of Fall Semester.
- BTU are often reported in thousands or millions (10^3 or 10^6). Please make sure
you are using the right number of zeros.
Natural gas:
1 MCF (thousand cubic feet) = 10 CCF (hundred cubic feet) = 10 therms = 1,000,000 BTU
Fuel oil #6: 1 gallon = 150,000 BTU
Fuel oil #2: 1 gallon = 138,000 BTU
Conversion factor for combined competition (automatically calculated using this factor):
1 MCF of natural gas (1 million BTU) burned to produce electricity in a conventional natural
gas plant yields 92.53 kWh. This is calculated using the Department of Energy heat rate estimate
of 10,807 BTU / kWh for conventional natural gas plants (the factor we use) as found in:
http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/aeo/assumption/pdf/electricity.pdf#page=3
Exceptional cases
- We are assuming that your campus burns some kind of fuel (natural gas, fuel oil,
etc.) and buys electricity for non-heating needs from off-campus. If you heat using
electricity, identify a way to isolate what portion is used for heating (convert to
BTU) and what is non-heating (leave in kWh). Otherwise, participate in the
electrical competition only and make sure you can record this fact as a note when
reporting data. 1 kWh of electricity converted into heat yields 3,413 BTU.
- We are assuming that no campuses use air conditioning in February, and thus are
not including Cooling Degree Days, which would significantly complicate
measuring electricity.
- If you generate electricity on campus in any significant quantity, please include it
in your electrical reporting. If this is not feasible, make sure you can record this as
a note. If you co-generate electricity with your heating system, please record the
amount of BTU your generator produces as heating, but count only purchased (not
co-generated) electricity in the electrical consumption.